Local business? Support local news on DallasTX.city

Back to Dallas

Bishop names a new senior pastor for Highland Park UMC; church council says its ministers stay in the pulpit

Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr. appointed Andy Lewis effective Thursday and moved Matt Tuggle and Paul Rasmussen to other duties. The church council, whose members voted to leave the denomination, says the move changes nothing for them.

Lena Stroud· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

October 29, 20262 min read

Three days after Highland Park United Methodist Church's members voted to leave the denomination, the United Methodist bishop for North Texas has put a new senior pastor in charge of the church, setting up competing claims to its leadership heading into Sunday.

Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr. of the Horizon Texas Conference said in a news release that Andy Lewis became senior pastor Thursday, Oct. 29, and that Matt Tuggle and Paul Rasmussen were reassigned "to other duties," People Newspapers reported. Saenz said on social media that Lewis, an ordained elder, had been working as his assistant.

The conference also said University Park United Methodist Church has agreed to temporarily host Highland Park members, beginning Sunday, Nov. 1.

"We will not walk away from you," Saenz wrote, adding that the conference's goal remains a United Methodist congregation at Hillcrest and Mockingbird that is connected to the wider church. "This is not the end of the story."

The council's response

The church council responded that the appointment "changes nothing" for the congregation. It said Tuggle, whom it calls its senior minister, will preach this Sunday at the church on Mockingbird and Hillcrest, and that it will keep standing behind Tuggle and Rasmussen, who it said never sought this conflict.

Members cast 4,775 votes on Oct. 25 and 26, with 90.35% in favor of separating. The council has said the congregation will begin worshiping as Highland Park Methodist Church on Sunday and aims to finish the separation by Dec. 1.

The conference maintains that a congregational vote alone does not end a church's ties to the denomination. Its lawsuit, filed in August, challenges changes church leaders made to the church's governing documents in 2022 and 2023, including filing a corporate name change with the Texas secretary of state that dropped "United" from the name.

Church leaders have said they made those changes in line with 2020 guidance from Texas courts on applying neutral principles of state law to church governance.

Sources

peoplenewspapers.com

hpumc.org

Share

Lena Stroud· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

Lena Stroud covers Dallas city hall, the council, and county government.

Related Stories

More in Texas