Back to Sport

Giants Convert 9 of 11 Third Downs and Sit on the Ball in 28-20 Opener

New York held possession for 36:40 and limited Dallas to two second-half drives in a season-opening win that exposed the Cowboys' rebuilt defense on early downs and third-and-manageable.

Dallas Newsroom

September 14, 20263 min read

NFLFinal
Dallas Cowboys20
New York Giants28

September 13, 2026

The New York Giants did not beat the Dallas Cowboys with a single explosive play. They beat them by refusing to leave the field.

On Sunday night at MetLife Stadium, New York converted 9 of 11 third downs and held the ball for 36 minutes, 40 seconds in a 28-20 season-opening win, according to the Cowboys' official game recap and a Field Level Media account carried by Reuters. Dallas managed just two second-half possessions. Both ended in touchdowns.

Neither mattered once the Giants drained the final 5:16 after Javonte Williams' late scoring catch.

That is the part of Week 1 a box score can understate. Jaxson Dart's 230 passing yards and three touchdowns, Cam Skattebo's 81 rushing yards and Isaiah Likely's eight catches for 78 yards and two scores fill the highlight packages. The possession math explains how a rebuilt Cowboys defense spent the night chasing rather than dictating.

How third downs became first downs

Dallas Cowboys.com's recap noted that New York averaged 4.5 yards per carry on 37 attempts and finished with 394 total yards to Dallas' 244. Short-yardage success on early downs set up manageable third downs; the Giants also converted longer ones when Dallas' secondary lost track of Likely and Devin Singletary in the flat.

The pattern peaked after halftime. Reuters reported an 8:01, 12-play drive to open the third quarter that ended with Dart's 2-yard touchdown pass to Likely, then an 8:11, 13-play march in the fourth that Singletary finished from nine yards out.

Between those drives, Dallas did score - Williams' 1-yard run pulled the Cowboys within 21-14 - but the offense never got a third crack once New York locked into clock control.

Coach Brian Schottenheimer, speaking afterward on DallasCowboys.com, said the Giants were the more physical team and that Dallas did not get enough pressure on Dart, who also ran for 54 yards. "He looked pretty comfortable back there," Schottenheimer said.

What the second half looked like from Dallas' sideline

Prescott finished 22 of 34 for 175 yards, two touchdowns and one interception, per Reuters. The Cowboys' two second-half scoring drives showed the offense could move when it had the ball. The problem was scarcity.

After Williams' 17-yard touchdown reception with 5:21 left, a taunting penalty pushed Brandon Aubrey's extra-point try back; Aubrey missed from 48 yards, leaving Dallas down eight, Reuters reported. The Giants never punted again.

Christian Parker's defense was making its regular-season debut after an offseason rebuild and with starters sitting out the preseason, the team recap noted. Week 1 offered no soft landing: a division rival under first-year Giants coach John Harbaugh that converted nearly everything on third down and lived in Dallas' backfield on early downs.

Looking ahead

Dallas hosts the Washington Commanders next Sunday at AT&T Stadium, the next chance to show whether the third-down failures were an opening-night coordination problem or a schematic gap. Schottenheimer framed the loss as "mile one of a 17-mile marathon" on the club site and said the group would be better.

The measurable standard from Sunday is clearer than the rhetoric: get off the field on third down, or the offense will keep watching from the sideline.

Sources

Dallas Cowboys

Dallas Cowboys

Reuters

Share

Dallas Newsroom

Reporting from Dallas and the surrounding area.

Related Stories

More in Weather