Local business? Support local news on DallasTX.city

Back to Dallas

Water projects bid under looser price weighting came in $49.6 million below estimates, though two went to the second-lowest bidder

A Dallas Water Utilities memo for Wednesday's Transportation and Infrastructure Committee reviews the first three contracts awarded since the council let price count for as little as 36.9% of a bid's score.

Wade Ramos· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

November 17, 20262 min read

Civic Infrastructure - illustration, Jake Team LLC

Dallas Water Utilities has awarded three construction contracts since the City Council let staff give price less weight when scoring bids for civil works, and all three came in under the engineers' cost estimates, according to a follow-up memo prepared for Wednesday's Transportation and Infrastructure Committee.

The three awards total about $176 million against estimates of roughly $225.6 million, a combined difference of about $49.6 million. In two of the three, the contract did not go to the lowest-priced proposer.

What changed

State law has required since September 2021 that price make up at least half of the scoring when a Texas local government picks a civil works contractor through competitive sealed proposals. The same statute lets a governing body drop that share to as low as 36.9% if it finds a lower weight is in the public interest.

The council made that finding on May 14, 2025, and delegated the decision on each project to department directors or their deputies so solicitations would not each need a separate council vote, the memo says.

For all of the water utility's projects since then, price counted for 40% of the score. The other 60% covered the contractor's approach to the work, its experience and qualifications, key personnel and use of small businesses under the city's DRIVE policy.

The three contracts

  • Lake June Pump Station and Reservoir Replacement, Package A, awarded Sept. 24, 2025: $72.7 million against a $76.8 million estimate. The winner was the second-lowest of three proposals.
  • Southwest Pipeline, Phase 1A, awarded Aug. 25, 2026: $89.9 million against a $130.8 million estimate, the largest gap. The winner was the second-lowest of four proposals.
  • 60-Inch Wastewater Rehabilitation Project, awarded Sept. 9, 2026: $13.3 million against an $18 million estimate. The winner had the lower price of two proposals.

No change orders have been issued on any of the three so far, the memo says. It does not say how much more the city is paying than the lowest proposal on the two contracts that went to the second-ranked bidder.

A fourth water utility project drew only one proposal. Staff are repackaging it to attract more contractors and plan to advertise it again later this year.

The memo, signed by Assistant City Manager Dev Rastogi, says staff will keep tracking the method as more contracts are awarded to judge whether giving price less than 50% of the weight remains effective.

The committee, chaired by council member Paul E. Ridley, meets at 9 a.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18, at City Hall. The same agenda includes interviews with nominees for the Dallas seats on the DFW Airport board and a bike plan update.

Sources

dallascityhall.com

webapi.legistar.com

webapi.legistar.com

Share

Wade Ramos· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

Wade Ramos writes about community life, schools, public safety, and local events in Dallas.

Related Stories

More in Texas